An Ordinance 11 complaint, vegetation encroachment, has been brought against the 2105 Harvey Road leasehold by the its neighbors 2107 Harvey Road and 2109 Harvey Road. These three leaseholds surround a piece of Village common ground known as the driveway section of the Pump Path.
The complete Pump Path runs from Harvey Road to Wind Lane, roughly southwest to northeast. On Google Maps, the path is shown as a section of Mill Lane, which it is not. The Pump Path can be considered to be in two distinct parts. Entering from Wind Lane, the Pump Path is a 6’ gravel footpath that terminates at the pavement section of the path. Entering from Harvey Road, the Pump Path is paved and acts as a driveway allowing access to 2107 Harvey Road. There is an easement that allows 2107 to drive across the Pump Path.
At issue is the vegetation encroachment from 2105 Harvey Road that cars and delivery vehicles have to push through plants and branches to gain access, marring the car paint. Tree branches overhanging the Village common ground have formed a barrier for delivery vehicles causing them to drive on the lawn of 2109 Harvey Road to avoid them. Further, there is concern that emergency response vehicles would not be able to access 2107. In the case of tree service vehicles for needed tree work, they are not able to enter at all. The vegetation is clearly an ongoing problem.
The encroachment was not accidental or through simple neglect of not maintaining their right of way. With time spent with the residents over multiple visits, we have learned that the plantings were intentional. Planting vegetation on the Village property, along their leasehold and on to Wind Lane, would give the path a more Garden City feel. Additionally, it would also give them more privacy. What do their neighbors think?
In the past, the 2107 and 2109 Harvey Road neighbors had attempted to settle the issue by contacting the 2105 Harvey Road leaseholders. The three leaseholds were not able to come to agreement on how much of the vegetation encroachment needed to be trimmed back. Next, the 2107 and 2109 Harvey Road neighbors came to the Civic Committee because this committee has roads and paths as part of its work scope and because the 2105 leaseholder is the Chair of the Safety Committee. From Ordinance 11, it is the Safety Committee that enforces encroachments.
That the 2105 leaseholder, is as a long term member and current Chair of the Safety Committee, and has not recused herself from deliberations surrounding her leasehold’s encroachment on the Pump Path, might be putting the Village in a position to be sued for malfeasance. This a case where an elected Village official is using their position in a committee that is charged with clearing encroachments, to violate a town ordinance and make their neighbors miserable. The Civic Committee in a certified letter delivered in October 2024, asked that the Chair of the Safety Committee to follow the Village Conflict of Interest Policy to recuse themselves from deliberating on the issue. During the last two regular Safety Meetings they have not done so.
Beginning in July 2024, members of the Civic Committee visited the Pump Path many times, speaking with residents of all three leaseholds in an attempt to amiably settle the issue. The 2105 leaseholder has refused offers by Civic Committee members to help clear the vegetation. What is obvious is that the vegetation encroachment has grown so far out over the Pump Path that the boundary between the 2105 leasehold and the Village common ground was ‘lost’. Civic Committee members were repeatedly warned that if trimming began, the Village would be sued for violating their U.S. Constitution 4th Amendment Rights of Search and Seizure. The Civic Committee has repeatedly told them that there is no interest in working inside their leasehold. We are only interested in recovering the Village common space.
These warnings lead to a ‘stand off’. We can’t clear the path if we don’t know where the edge was. The leaseholder is repeatedly threatening to sue. In July 2024, the committee voted to hire a surveyor and began to seek bids. Eventually, “The PELSA Company” was hired. PELSA is a company providing engineering, surveying and environmental sciences services. PELSA began to survey the Pump Path to mark existing pins and replace those that might missing. PELSA would also provide a file of the total Pump Path and surrounding 5 leaseholds. Over the course of several months a team of two surveyors working under the direction of an engineer, took measurements of the area beyond these 5 leaseholds, going as far as Hillside Road and going down Wind Lane.
The current situation is this. The pins are all in and have been freshly marked with paint and some with flagged stakes. We know where the edges of the Pump Path are. There is a substantial vegetation encroachment over the Pump Path that needs to be removed. The Pump Path paved area is about 1/2 Village land and 1/2 leaseholder land. The 1/2 leaseholder land is on the 2109 and 2107 leaseholds. An easement was found in the Trustee records that gives permanent access to the ‘land locked’ 2107 leasehold over the 2109 leasehold. Committee members have trimmed tree branches over the Village common space allow emergency vehicles in. Further tree work is needed.
Months have passed and the residents of 2105 Harvey have not cleared the vegetation to their leasehold boundary and returned the Village common space.
The Safety Committee voted to follow Ordinance 11 and sent a certified letter to the Chair of the Safety Committee and 2105 leaseholder telling them to clear the encroachment. The leaseholder appealed the decision. The next step per Ordinance 11 was a meeting by a three-person board composed of a Safety Committee member, Community Planning Committee member and a Civic Committee member. The Ordinance 11 Appeal Board met on February 24th, 2025 at the Buzz Ware Village Center. The leaseholder gave an explanation as why the encroachment should remain. Support from other speakers was allowed. It was noted that the landowners, the Trustees, have accepted the new survey plan. It was also noted that there was no rebuttal of the survey plan from the leaseholder. After a time, the public was asked to leave the room so the Board could deliberate. The result is the Board voted unanimously against the leaseholder holding them in violation of Ordinance 11. The leaseholder of 2105 Harvey appealed the verdict of the 3-person board. The next step per Ordinance 11 is for the Town Assembly to hear and judge the violation.
Updated March 19th, 2025
2024 Pump Path survey plan and details
The area in blue is the Village’s Pump Path.
Click here for detail: Pump Path in blue
The area in green is the vegetation encroachment across the Village’s Pump Path.
Click here for detail: Vegetation Encroachment
Both the Pump Path (blue) with encroaching vegetation
Click here for detail: Vegetation covering the Pump Path
The area in gold is the Easement allowing access to ‘landlocked’ 2107 Harvey Road
Click here for detail: Easement over 2109 Harvey Rd leasehold
The complete 2024 Pump Path survey plan
Click here for The PELSA Company Pump Path survey plan 2024
Ordinance 11: Encroachments on the Rights of Way
Click here for Ordinance 11: Encroachments on the Rights of Way
Easement that allows 2107 Harvey Rd access to Harvey Road over 2109 Harvey Rd leasehold
Click here for Lot 3B Easement
Question: About overhead obstructions. What is the MINIMUM height for Emergency Vehicle Access?
Answer: “13.5 ft (4.1 m) of unobstructed vertical clearance”
National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) Fire Apparatus Access Roads
Click here for NFPA Fire Apparatus Access Roads
Brooke Bovard, as a long term member and current Chair of the Safety Committee, has not recused herself from deliberations surrounding her leasehold’s encroachment on the Pump Path.
Arden’s Conflict of Interest Policy
Click here for Conflict of Interest Policy
Photo Gallery
Pictures taken from July 2024 to December 2024
The Pump Path entrance at Harvey Road with a not permitted driveway access to the Pump Path.

At Harvey Road the Pump Path width is 10′ 6 1/4″.
The second additional width, 4′ 10 1/4″, is the easement width across the 2109 Harvey Rd leasehold.

The Pump Path pins mark the entrance from Wind Lane.

The fence is inside the Village common area. Note the overhanging vegetation.

Looking East at the Pump Path entrance to Harvey Road.
Imagine for moment, turning left to go towards Claymont.

Looking towards Harvey Rd, a faded red circle marks the edge of the Pump Path that divides the pavement.
To the left is the Pump Path. To the right is the 2107 Harvey Rd. leasehold.
Note the vegetation on the left growing into the Pump Path.

